Oilers vs. Stars Game 2 Preview & Best Bets (May 23, 2025)
Dallas looked like they were in trouble in Game 1 but turned it around with a five-goal (that’s crazy in hockey) third period, which erased a two-goal deficit, and they won 6–3. Edmonton is under pressure to win this one so they don’t go home down two games. The Stars are clicking on all fronts with special teams and getting great play in the net. Game 2 will tell us if the Oilers can bounce back or if Dallas is gonna skate away with it.
Game 2 Snapshot
- Matchup: Edmonton Oilers vs. Dallas Stars
- Series Status: DAL leads 1-0
- Date & Time: Friday, May 23, at 8:00 pm ET
- Location: American Airlines Center, Dallas, TX
- Broadcast: ESPN, ESPN+, SN, CBC
Prediction Breakdown
48.1%
51.9%
According to GamblingSite.com
Game 1 Recap: Stars’ Third-Period Surge
Dallas was down 3–1 going into the third period, but took over the game in the last 20 minutes.
- The Stars scored five unanswered—there were three power-play goals in five minutes.
- Tyler Seguin was the MVP with two goals and an assist.
- Jake Oettinger made 24 saves and rallied as the Oilers kept shooting the pucks at him.
- Edmonton’s penalty kill didn’t hold—it gave up three goals on four chances.
- Stuart Skinner had a hard time stopping the bleeding—all five goals got past him in the third.
Key Storylines
After the way Game 1 went down, there are some things that are pretty hard to ignore going into Game 2.
Edmonton Oilers
- Offensive Leaders: Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl carried the load once again, but they didn’t get much support past the top line.
- Goaltending Concerns: Stuart Skinner gave up five goals in the third period and looked totally lost as it happened.
- Special Teams: The penalty kill collapsed, allowing three power-play goals in five minutes and giving control back to Dallas.
Dallas Stars
- Power Play Efficiency: The Stars went 3-for-3 on the man advantage in the third, capitalizing on every chance they got.
- Depth Scoring: Seguin, Granlund, and Johnston all found the scoresheet—Dallas didn’t need its top line to win the game.
- Defensive Resilience: Oettinger stayed in the game, made the stops, and looked right at home in the net when it mattered.
Betting Odds & Lines for Game 2
Where are the odds for Game 2? Here are the latest for the Oilers vs. Stars Game 2, via FanDuel Sportsbook!
| Team | Spread | Moneyline | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
Oilers | +1.5 (-250) | -102 | Over 6.5 (+100) |
Stars | -1.5 (+198) | -118 | Under 6.5 (-122) |
Best Bets for Game 2
Game 1 opened up the door for value on both sides of the market. Below is what looks good going into Game 2:
- Moneyline: Stars -124 – Dallas took over in the third and looked really balanced across all three zones. At home, they’re in a strong spot to make it 2–0.
- Total Goals: Under 6.5 (-110) – Game 1 went over, but it took a total collapse and a surge of power-play goals to get there. Expect both teams to tighten up defensively.
- Prop Bet: Tyler Seguin Anytime Goal +240 – He’s skating like a madman and coming off a two-goal night, and still getting time with skilled linemates and on the power play.
Projected Lineups
Barring any late changes, here are the projected lineups for Game 2.
Edmonton Oilers
- Forwards: McDavid – Draisaitl – Hyman
- Defense: Nurse – Bouchard
- Goalie: Stuart Skinner
Dallas Stars
- Forwards: Seguin – Hintz – Pavelski
- Defense: Heiskanen – Lindell
- Goalie: Jake Oettinger
Prediction Time: Who Takes Game 2?
FYI: Odds can change right up until the puck drops, especially with the lineup. Always check your preferred sportsbook for the latest numbers! And as always, bet smart, stick to your limits, and keep it in check (aka gamble responsibly).
Dallas proved in Game 1 that they don’t need a full 60 minutes to do a lot of damage; they just need a stretch where the Oilers lose their structure. Special teams made all the difference, and Oettinger gave them an amazing presence in the net. Edmonton will push back, but unless they solve their penalty kill and get better from Skinner? It’s gonna be a chase.
Final Game 2 Prediction: Dallas Stars 4, Edmonton Oilers 2
Dallas will ride the special teams advantage and depth scoring to take a 2–0 lead before the series heads to Edmonton. The Stars don’t need a full-on reset; they just need to keep doing what worked in the third period of Game 1. Edmonton’s top line will generate chances, but unless the goaltending improves, they’ll be playing catch-up again.
