Bills vs. Texans Prediction (9/13/2026): NFL Week 1 Pick, Odds & Best Bet
Joe Brady’s first game as an NFL head coach comes in the one building Josh Allen has never solved: four trips to Houston, four losses, and the Bills and Texans have never combined for more than 43 points in any of them. With Houston’s defense still built around Danielle Hunter and Will Anderson Jr., and Houston’s offense missing three starters, the number that matters most here is the total. Our best bet is Under 44.5 total points at -110 (FanDuel), a standard one-unit play rather than something to hammer.
Both teams went 12-5 last season and both went out in the Divisional Round, so this is a heavyweight opener priced like a coin flip, with Buffalo laying 1.5 points on the road. The side is a guess we would rather not pay for. The question we can answer is whether a Texans defense that allowed a league-low 16.6 points per game can drag another meeting into the low 40s. New to totals? Our over/under betting guide explains the number.
Reliant Stadium, Houston, TX
Brady’s Debut Comes With a New Defense and a New No. 1 Receiver
Buffalo fired Sean McDermott after January’s overtime loss in Denver and promoted Brady, its offensive coordinator. He keeps the play sheet, Pete Carmichael Jr. steps in as coordinator, and the front office traded a second-round pick to Chicago for DJ Moore. Moore had two 1,100-yard seasons under Brady in Carolina, and he joins a quarterback coming off 3,668 passing yards, 25 touchdown passes and 14 rushing scores.
The defense is the unknown. Jim Leonhard arrives from Denver to install a 3-4 base over a unit that ranked 28th against the run last season and allowed eight touchdown runs of 30-plus yards. Houston is running it back: DeMeco Ryans, Nick Caley and C.J. Stroud all return.
Four Trips to Houston, Four Losses, and Never 44 Points
Allen is 0-4 as a starter in Houston. He accounted for two touchdowns across the four games, and in the most recent one, Houston’s 23-19 win last November, the Texans sacked him a career-high eight times for minus-70 yards while Calen Bullock picked him off twice.
| Allen in Houston | Final | Combined points |
|---|---|---|
| Oct. 14, 2018 | Texans 20, Bills 13 | 33 |
| Jan. 4, 2020 (Wild Card) | Texans 22, Bills 19 (OT) | 41 |
| Oct. 6, 2024 | Texans 23, Bills 20 | 43 |
| Nov. 20, 2025 | Texans 23, Bills 19 | 42 |
The under is 7-3 in the last 10 meetings, and Houston has covered six of them. That is a pattern, not a projection, and 44.5 sits above all four results.
Houston Is Missing Three Starters and Buffalo Is Missing Almost Nobody
Houston’s official Week 1 injury report has no game designations. The absences that matter were settled weeks ago, plus one on Friday: rookie defensive tackle Kayden McDonald (ankle) went on injured reserve, a depth loss up front.
Jayden Higgins is out for the season. The projected No. 2 receiver tore his ACL in an August joint practice and sits on injured reserve after a 41-catch, six-touchdown rookie year. Tank Dell opened the year on the reserve/PUP list with his knee, so late-August signings Sterling Shepard and Zay Jones fill in behind Nico Collins, Xavier Hutchinson and Jaylin Noel. That is a group built to move the chains, not to win a shootout.
Joe Mixon is on the non-football injury list for at least four games with his foot, which leaves David Montgomery and second-year back Woody Marks to carry a run game that ranked 22nd last season.
Buffalo’s list is three names, all questionable. Running back Ty Johnson (hamstring) was limited Friday after a month off, defensive lineman T.J. Sanders (knee) is slated to start up front and is the one to watch, and defensive back Jordan Hancock (quad) practiced fully Friday.
What Bills -1.5 and a 44.5 Total Are Telling You
Buffalo is a 1.5-point favorite with the total at 44.5 across the market. At FanDuel the Bills are -1.5 (-105) and -112 on the moneyline, the Texans are +1.5 (-115) and -104, and the total is 44.5 at -110 each way (all subject to change). Vig removed, that moneyline implies roughly a 51% chance for Buffalo, the market’s read rather than ours.
The Spread Hasn’t Moved All Week, but the Price Has
FanDuel had the Bills at -102 on the spread and -110 on the moneyline when Sports Illustrated’s preview ran on Tuesday; by Saturday morning those numbers were -105 and -116, and by midday the moneyline had eased back to -112. The total has sat at 44.5 the entire time, the over briefly carried -118 juice before settling at -110, and BetRivers is the outlier at Bills -2 and 45. That wobble is worth noting, not proof of anything: the market leaned toward Buffalo midweek and has given some of it back. Shop the number with our line-shopping tool.
Hunter and Anderson Against a Reshuffled Buffalo Interior
Hunter (15 sacks) and Anderson (12) combined for 27 last season. Buffalo answers with a new left guard in Alec Anderson, a center in Connor McGovern coming back from a hamstring injury, and no fullback on the roster for the first time in Allen’s career. Sacks stall drives, and stalled drives keep totals under the number.
Houston’s offense caps the other side. Stroud threw for 3,041 yards, 19 touchdowns and eight interceptions in 14 games last season with Higgins on the field, and Montgomery (716 yards in Detroit last year) and Marks (703 as a rookie) inherit a 22nd-ranked run game behind a rebuilt interior. Houston scored 20, 22, 23 and 23 in its four home wins over Allen and may not be built to produce much more.
Where We Land: Under 44.5, Sized at One Unit
Take Under 44.5 at -110. Houston allowed the fewest points in the NFL last season and sacked Allen eight times in this building in November, and its own offense is missing Higgins, Dell and Mixon. The counterweight is real: Allen accounted for 39 touchdowns last season, Moore gives him a receiver Brady already knows how to use, and Leonhard’s defense has never played a live snap together, so two explosive drives clear this number. That is why it is one unit, not a max play. Houston at close to even money is defensible if you need a side, but the total is the bet we are grading. The rest of the Sunday board is in our NFL Week 1 picks.
Play Safe: Gambling should be fun, not stressful. Set limits, stick to your budget, and never chase losses. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-MY-RESET or visit ncpgambling.org. For more resources, see our Responsible Gambling page.
Frequently Asked Questions
Kickoff, the injury picture, and why the total gets our money instead of the side.
What time is Bills vs. Texans on Sunday, and what channel is it on?
Kickoff is 1:00 p.m. ET on Sunday, September 13, at Reliant Stadium in Houston, and the game airs on CBS.
Is Josh Allen really winless in Houston?
Yes. Allen is 0-4 as a starter in Houston: 20-13 in 2018 (he left with an elbow injury), 22-19 in overtime in the January 2020 wild-card game, 23-20 in 2024 on a 59-yard field goal at the buzzer, and 23-19 last November with eight sacks taken. No meeting there has produced more than 43 points.
Who is out for the Texans and Bills in Week 1?
Houston has no game designations, but receivers Jayden Higgins (injured reserve) and Tank Dell (reserve/PUP), running back Joe Mixon (non-football injury list) and rookie defensive tackle Kayden McDonald (injured reserve) are out. Buffalo lists running back Ty Johnson (hamstring), defensive lineman T.J. Sanders (knee) and defensive back Jordan Hancock (quad) as questionable.
Why bet the under instead of taking Houston +1.5 at home?
Because the total has the clearer case. Every one of Allen’s four games in Houston stayed under 44 points, Houston allowed a league-low 16.6 points per game last season, and the Texans’ offense is missing three starters, while the side is a coin flip. Houston at close to even money is defensible, but Under 44.5 at -110 (FanDuel) is the bet we are grading, at one unit. Odds are subject to change.
