NFL MVP Odds After Nine Weeks: Which Candidates Are Overpriced?
Joe Burrow is the MVP favorite at the halfway point of the season. After Buffalo’s 23-6 win in Minnesota on Monday night, DraftKings has Burrow at +210 and Josh Allen at +240, with Brock Purdy third at +425. Our read of the NFL MVP odds after nine weeks: Trevor Lawrence at +900 is still the most overpriced candidate, Caleb Williams at +1600 joins him, and Patrick Mahomes stays on the list at +3000 even after his price fell apart. Two things changed since our last update after Week 5. Dak Prescott comes off the list, because DraftKings no longer prices him shorter than +10000, and Williams goes on it after a four-interception night.
We put the top eight names through the same three tests every week: where each quarterback ranks in ESPN’s Total QBR, how much of his team’s record is his doing, and whether Kalshi, the exchange where traders set the price themselves, charges as much as the sportsbook does. Sportsbook prices are the DraftKings board Sports Illustrated published on November 10, 2026, after the Monday game, and Fox Sports printed the same top three. That board lists 13 players and says nobody else is shorter than +10000, so this week’s shares are scaled across those 13 names. Kalshi prices are our own pull at 12:18 p.m. ET. Every percentage below belongs to a market, not to us.
Lawrence is still the most overpriced: fifth on the board at +900, ninth in QBR, and a bigger slice of DraftKings’ board (8.1%) than of Kalshi’s (7.1%). Williams is +1600 after missing three games and throwing four interceptions on Sunday night. Mahomes is +3000 while ranking 13th in QBR, and the exchange prices him near +4900. Burrow, Allen and Purdy are priced about right. Give Jordan Love a week before you chase his jump from +2500 to +650.
Who Is the NFL MVP Favorite After Nine Weeks?
Joe Burrow, at +210 at DraftKings, with Josh Allen next at +240. The two were tied at +240 on Monday morning, and Allen’s quiet passing night in Minnesota gave Burrow the top spot alone. Here is the top of the market on Tuesday:
| Player | DraftKings | Break-even | Share of DK board | Kalshi bid / ask (cents) | Share of Kalshi board | ESPN QBR (rank) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Joe Burrow, Bengals | +210 | 32.3% | 26.1% | 32 / 33 | 30.8% | 79.5 (2nd) |
| Josh Allen, Bills | +240 | 29.4% | 23.8% | 25 / 26 | 24.2% | 76.0 (4th) |
| Brock Purdy, 49ers | +425 | 19.0% | 15.4% | 16 / 17 | 15.6% | 81.4 (1st) |
| Jordan Love, Packers | +650 | 13.3% | 10.8% | 13 / 14 | 12.8% | 70.2 (8th) |
| Trevor Lawrence, Jaguars | +900 | 10.0% | 8.1% | 7 / 8 | 7.1% | 66.9 (9th) |
| Caleb Williams, Bears | +1600 | 5.9% | 4.8% | 3 / 4 | 3.3% | 72.2 (7th) |
| Patrick Mahomes, Chiefs | +3000 | 3.2% | 2.6% | 1 / 2 | 1.4% | 60.9 (13th) |
| Drake Maye, Patriots | +4500 | 2.2% | 1.8% | 0 / 1 | 0.5% | 74.3 (5th) |
- Break-even is how often a ticket at the DraftKings price has to win just to get your money back. It includes the book’s margin.
- Share of the board strips that margin out. The 13 prices DraftKings had on November 10, 2026 add up to 123.4%. A standard -110 point spread adds up to about 104.8%, so an awards board carries far more margin. We scaled both markets to 100% across the same 13 names.
- Kalshi prices are in cents on a contract that pays $1. The midpoints of all 49 names on its board add up to 123.5 cents, so a 33-cent contract is not a 33% chance until you scale it the same way.
- QBR is ESPN’s Total QBR through Week 9. It counts sacks, fumbles and rushing along with passing, which is why it can disagree with passer rating.
- Games played differ. Love and Maye have played nine (no bye yet), Williams six (he missed three with a hamstring injury), and the other five eight.
The two markets agree on the order at the top and disagree in the middle. Kalshi traders are more bullish than DraftKings on Burrow (30.8% of the exchange’s board against 26.1% of the sportsbook’s) and on Love (12.8% against 10.8%). Lawrence, Williams and Mahomes run the other way: all three take up more of the sportsbook’s board than the exchange’s.
Which NFL MVP Candidates Are Overpriced Right Now?
Lawrence, Williams and Mahomes, in that order. All three are priced ahead of what they have done on the field, and in each case the exchange asks less than the sportsbook does.
- Trevor Lawrence (+900): fifth-shortest price on the board, ninth in QBR, and 8.1% of DraftKings’ board against 7.1% of Kalshi’s.
- Caleb Williams (+1600): seventh in QBR over six games, with eight touchdown passes and five interceptions. He takes 4.8% of DraftKings’ board and 3.3% of Kalshi’s.
- Patrick Mahomes (+3000): 13th in QBR with an elbow to watch, and 2.6% of DraftKings’ board against 1.4% of Kalshi’s.
Two facts about the award explain why we weigh quarterback play and team record this heavily. A quarterback has won MVP in each of the last 13 seasons, and the 50 voters fill out a ranked five-man ballot after the regular season, so the full 17 games count. Last year’s vote shows how fine the margins get: Matthew Stafford beat Drake Maye by five points, 366 to 361. Overpriced here means the price asks you to believe more than nine weeks of evidence supports. Any of these three can still win it.
Why Is Trevor Lawrence Still the Most Overpriced MVP Candidate?
Because the Jacksonville defense is doing much of the work his price gives him credit for. Lawrence is +900, the fifth-shortest price on the board, while ranking ninth in Total QBR at 66.9. The Jaguars are 6-2 and have allowed 121 points in eight games, second-fewest in the league behind Minnesota.
His passing line is efficient: 1,932 yards, 18 touchdowns, four interceptions and a 111.7 passer rating. The volume is not there, though. He ranks 15th in passing yards, and QBR charges him for 13 sacks. Last Thursday in Baltimore he went 16 of 26 for 242 yards and a touchdown in a 33-10 win over a Ravens team starting Joe Fagnano at quarterback, per the Jaguars’ box score. A quarterback on a team that wins that way needs bigger numbers of his own to finish first on 50 ballots.
| Trevor Lawrence MVP price | Price | Break-even |
|---|---|---|
| DraftKings, preseason | +2200 | 4.3% |
| DraftKings, September 28 | +1400 | 6.7% |
| DraftKings, October 13 | +750 | 11.8% |
| DraftKings, November 10 | +900 | 10.0% |
| BetMGM, November 10 | +750 | 11.8% |
| Kalshi ask, November 10 (8 cents) | about +1150 | 8.0% |
The exchange has not moved on him in four weeks. Kalshi had Lawrence at 7 cents bid and 8 asked on October 13, 2026, and the same on Tuesday, while DraftKings drifted from +750 to +900. The books also disagree with each other: Yahoo Sports reported BetMGM at +750 on November 10, so the shorter sportsbook number is the one to avoid. He was our sleeper at +2200 in our preseason NFL MVP best bets, and that ticket still looks good. A +900 ticket is a different bet at well under half the payout.
Is Caleb Williams Overpriced at +1600?
Yes. Chicago is 7-2, but Williams has started six of those games, and his season line of 1,546 yards, eight touchdowns and five interceptions is short of what a 16-1 MVP price asks for. He ranks seventh in QBR at 72.2 and 22nd in passing yards.
- The missed games: a hamstring injury in Week 2 kept him out of Weeks 3 through 5, and the Bears went 2-1 without him. Voters notice games a team wins without its quarterback.
- Sunday night: 22 of 37 for 279 yards, two touchdowns and four interceptions in a 27-24 win over Tampa Bay, which Chicago survived despite five giveaways, per Pro Football Talk.
- The price: DraftKings had him at +1000 on Monday morning and +1600 on Tuesday. BetMGM was at 30-1, and Kalshi’s 4-cent ask works out to about +2400 before fees.
- The schedule: the Bears are on their bye in Week 10, so his number cannot get better until November 22 at the earliest.
DraftKings has already lengthened him once, and +1600 is still the shortest of the three prices we checked. He takes 4.8% of DraftKings’ board and 3.3% of Kalshi’s.
Is Patrick Mahomes Still Overpriced After Falling to +3000?
Yes, even after the fall. Mahomes was +650 after Week 5 and is +3000 now, but he ranks 13th in QBR at 60.9, and the exchange prices him far longer than the sportsbook does: 1 cent bid and 2 asked, about +4900 before fees.
Kansas City is 6-2, and the defense has allowed 143 points, third-fewest in the league. Mahomes has 2,037 yards, 14 touchdowns and four interceptions, a 101.8 passer rating that ranks fourth among the eight names in our table. Sunday was one of his better days, 23 of 31 for 242 yards and two touchdowns in a 35-12 win over the Jets, and it ended a two-game losing streak.
Then there is the elbow. Mahomes took a hit on his right (throwing) arm late in the second quarter, and ESPN reported Monday that Andy Reid called him day-to-day after tests that Reid described as more good news than bad. Whether he practices fully this week is open, and the Chiefs play at Atlanta on November 15, 2026. His comeback from last December’s ACL and LCL tear is its own award race, which we cover in our Comeback Player of the Year odds breakdown. For MVP, +3000 takes 2.6% of DraftKings’ board against 1.4% of Kalshi’s, a markup of more than four-fifths.
Should You Wait on Jordan Love After His Jump to +650?
Yes, give it a week. Love went from +2500 to +650 at DraftKings on one game, and he is not on our overpriced list, because Kalshi traders price him even higher than the sportsbook does. One big night is still a thin reason to buy at the new number.
The game was big. Love threw for 372 yards and three touchdowns and ran for a fourth in a 45-27 win at New England, per NFL.com’s Week 9 recap. He leads the league with 2,618 passing yards, has 19 touchdown passes against six interceptions, and Green Bay is 6-3. The rest of the case is softer: eighth in QBR at 70.2, a 97.9 passer rating and 17 sacks taken. Kalshi’s Love contract was 3 cents bid and 4 asked before Sunday’s game and is 13 and 14 now, so both markets made the same leap at once.
A price that drops by three-quarters on one result is the pattern we describe in our guide to spotting overreactions in betting markets. The same game sent Drake Maye the other way: three first-half interceptions left him tied for the league lead with 11, and he dropped to +4500 even though he ranks fifth in QBR.
What Happened to Dak Prescott and Lamar Jackson?
Both are off the DraftKings board, which now lists nobody else shorter than +10000. Prescott comes off our overpriced list for that reason: a price that long no longer asks much of him. He ranks third in QBR at 77.0, but Dallas is 4-5.
Jackson was the name we said to wait on after Week 5. He came back from his ankle sprain, then hurt his right thumb on the first play at Buffalo on November 1 and will have surgery and go on injured reserve. Coach Jesse Minter said the injury could potentially end his season. Baltimore is 4-5, and Kalshi has Jackson at 0 cents bid, 1 asked.
Which MVP Candidates Are Priced Fairly?
Burrow, Allen and Purdy. Each has the production to match his price, and the two markets price all three within about five points of each other.
- Joe Burrow (+210): second in QBR at 79.5, with 23 touchdown passes, six interceptions, a 74.0% completion rate and a 114.8 passer rating, plus three rushing scores. Cincinnati is 6-2 on four straight wins after he went 24 of 29 for 271 yards, three touchdowns and a rushing score against Atlanta in Madrid. Kalshi is higher on him than DraftKings, and its 33-cent ask is about +203 before fees, so +210 is the better of the two numbers.
- Josh Allen (+240): fourth in QBR at 76.0 on a 7-1 team, with 12 touchdown passes, six interceptions and nine rushing touchdowns. Monday was ordinary by his standard, 21 of 31 for 234 yards, a touchdown and an interception in the 23-6 win, per NFL.com. The two markets have him at 23.8% and 24.2% of their boards.
- Brock Purdy (+425): first in QBR at 81.4, with 17 touchdown passes, five interceptions, a 109.8 passer rating and eight sacks taken on a 7-1 team. He went 17 of 25 for 232 yards and two touchdowns, and ran for another, in a 38-17 win over the Raiders. The caveat is volume: he ranks 14th in passing yards. Kalshi’s 17-cent ask is about +488, so +425 is the shorter price.
How Should You Bet the NFL MVP Market Now?
Shop harder than you have been, because the books and the exchange disagree by more on the second tier than at the top. There are nine weeks left, and here’s how we’d handle it:
- Pass on Lawrence at +900, and especially at +750. The exchange has him closer to +1150.
- Pass on Williams until the Bears play again. He has a bye and a four-interception game to answer for.
- Wait on Mahomes’ elbow before you even consider him. The Chiefs’ Wednesday practice report will tell you more than the price does.
- Don’t chase Love’s move this week. See whether a second big game follows the first.
- Check the exchange before you bet. Kalshi was lower than the sportsbook on Lawrence, Williams and Mahomes and higher on Burrow and Love. Our Kalshi review explains how its contracts and fees work.
- Shop the books. BetMGM had Lawrence 150 points shorter than DraftKings on the same day. Compare DraftKings with BetMGM and at least one other book before you take any of these.
- Keep it small. An MVP ticket ties up your money until February, and one injury can end it.
🕑 Odds as of: November 10, 2026, with all of Week 9 played. DraftKings prices are the 13-name board Sports Illustrated published that day, and Fox Sports showed the same top three. BetMGM prices are as reported by Yahoo Sports the same day. Kalshi prices are our 12:18 p.m. ET read of its MVP market. Award prices move after every game, so check the current number at your own book, and see this week’s lines on our live NFL odds board.
Burrow, Allen and Purdy have earned the top of the board, and the order among them will keep changing with every prime-time game. The prices to be careful with sit just below them, where a strong defense, a hot team record or a famous name has kept a ticket shorter than the quarterback’s own play supports. Lawrence at +900 is the clearest case, Williams at +1600 the newest one. Let the second half of the season tell you whether those prices were right.
Play Safe: Gambling should be fun, not stressful. Set limits, stick to your budget, and never chase losses. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-MY-RESET or visit ncpgambling.org. For more resources, see our Responsible Gambling page.
NFL MVP Odds FAQ
Quick answers to the questions we’re hearing most about the MVP race and this week’s prices.
Who Is the Favorite to Win NFL MVP Right Now?
Joe Burrow. DraftKings had the Bengals quarterback at +210 on November 10, 2026, the day after Buffalo beat Minnesota 23-6, with Josh Allen next at +240 and Brock Purdy at +425. Kalshi traders had the same order, with Burrow at 32 cents bid and 33 asked against Allen’s 25 and 26.
Which NFL MVP Candidates Are Overpriced After Nine Weeks?
Trevor Lawrence, Caleb Williams and Patrick Mahomes. Lawrence is the fifth choice at +900 while ranking ninth in QBR, Williams is +1600 after starting six of Chicago’s nine games, and Mahomes is +3000 while ranking 13th in QBR with an elbow injury to monitor. All three take a bigger share of DraftKings’ board than of Kalshi’s.
Is Joe Burrow Worth a Bet at +210 to Win MVP?
It’s a fair price, and no bargain. Burrow is second in QBR, leads the league with 23 touchdown passes and has Cincinnati at 6-2. A +210 ticket needs him to win the award 32.3% of the time to break even. Kalshi’s 33-cent ask on November 10, 2026 worked out to about +203 before fees, so the sportsbook number was slightly better.
Why Doesn’t a 33-Cent Kalshi Price Mean a 33% Chance to Win MVP?
Because the prices on the whole board add up to more than a dollar. On November 10, 2026 the midpoints of all 49 names in Kalshi’s MVP market summed to 123.5 cents. Scaled back to 100%, Joe Burrow’s 32-to-33-cent contract was about a 26% share of the board. Sportsbook boards work the same way: the 13 MVP prices DraftKings had that day added up to 123.4%.
Can Patrick Mahomes Still Win MVP After Hurting His Elbow?
It’s a long way back. Andy Reid called Mahomes day-to-day on November 9, 2026, after he took a hit on his throwing arm against the Jets, and his status for the November 15, 2026 game at Atlanta was not settled. He is +3000 at DraftKings and ranks 13th in QBR, so he needs both a clean bill of health and a much stronger second half.
Week 10 NFL Picks Against the Spread: Best ATS Bets for Every GameKevin Roberts · November 14, 2026
Commanders vs. Giants Player Props: 5 Best Bets for Thursday Night FootballKevin Roberts · November 12, 2026
Does Rest Really Matter in the NFL? Short Weeks, Bye Weeks and Betting ResultsKevin Roberts · November 11, 2026
Kevin RobertsDFS & Sports Betting WriterKevin Roberts is a fantasy football, DFS, and sports betting analyst with over 20 years of experience and a registered expert at FantasyPros.com. He has contributed analysis to leading sports media brands including Bleacher Report, FFToday, and GridironExperts, and has published thousands of articles across the industry. He is also the founder of the DFS advice site DFSBuild.com and the creator of The DFS Build on YouTube. A consistently profitable DFS player on DraftKings and FanDuel, Kevin is known for disciplined, value-based strategy and numerous three- and four-figure wins. His expertise spans daily fantasy sports, player props, futures and prediction markets, season-long and dynasty formats, and sports betting picks—all backed by a commitment to publicly graded results and a transparent track record.
Full bio & contact